Labour appeal court ruling on temporary employment. Section 197 of the labour relations act deals with the transfer of a business and the rights of employees affected by such a transaction. However karnataka governmentwhere most of the it industries are situated renewed the blanket cover to it industries for a period of five years in 20 from the provisions of the industrial emplo. This case reiterates and reasserts the nature and scope of application of section 197 of the lra. Labour appeal court ruling on temporary employment services. Is there any law where software companies can be covered. In terms of section 197 a business includes the whole or a part of any business, trade, undertaking or service. Does insourcing trigger employee transfer obligations in south africa.
The act in section 197 thereof deals with the transfer of a contract of employment and defines. Labour smart training pty ltd, strives to be the best provider of quality training in the fields of labour and employment law, and human resources. Sep 19, 2014 looking to eu and uk jurisprudence sa cases show that section 197 may apply where there is a change in service provider, provided that must be service, not goods labour broker employees franman. Section 197 of this specifically says that the staff must be taken over by the new owner on the same. Agenda for section 21 meeting, document, labour law, south. Business sold as a going concern legal obligations of the old and. In my view, section 1972 clearly establishes a default position. Aug 22, 2016 if so, then make sure that you know about and comply with the provisions of the labour relations act. Where a company, company a, concludes an outsourcing agreement with company b, such agreement subsequently terminates by effluxion of time and a similar outsourcing arrangement is then concluded with company c, company c will be responsible for taking over the employees who previously performed the services provided it can be said that a transfer of a business as a going concern has occurred as contemplated by section 197 of the labour relations act 66 of 1995, as amended lra. A critical analysis of section 197 of the labour relations act 66 of 1995 as amended taking into consideration the elements of section 197, the definition and case law. Whistleblowing employees are also protected by sections 1862d and section 1871h of the labour relations act lra. Our labour legislation historically tended towards express allocations of employment law obligations to a single employer in both the 1956 and 1995 lra, but this is no longer the case.
An analysis of employee protection in business transfers. Labour law also known as labor law or employment law mediates the relationship between workers, employing entities, trade unions and the government. Contract transfers a section 197 takeover hr pulse. Section 198 of the labour relations act lra says a labour broker is anyone who gets money for supplying workers to a client company and pays the workers wages. The legal question that arose was whether such insourcing would trigger section 197 of the labour relations act the lra, which sets out. For certain intangibles, the depreciation period is specified in the law and. The labour court concluded that a transfer in terms of section 197 had taken place with effect from 1 august 2012, and that the employees had been transferred to city power in accordance with the provisions of section 197. Labour all bangalore lawyer develops software for labour. Supervision sections 108115 library of translated thai law. Section 197 intangibles include any right under a license, contract, or other arrangement providing for the use of any section 197 intangible. Publication 535 business expenses section 197 intangibles.
In terms of section 197 of the labour relations act the lra, the sale of a business as a going concern takes place subject to the provisions of the lra. Does insourcing trigger employee transfer obligations in. There are a few mechanisms in labour law that now become relevant through the above verdict. The consequences of section 197 may be varied by agreement. Contact us to understand how complicheck can help your company stay. Section 197 of the labour relations act deals with the transfer of a business and the rights of employees affected by such a. Section 1972c effectively allows the employee to sue the new employer even if it was the old employer who retrenched the employee unfairly. May 18, 2015 section 197 of the labour relations act lra places heavy responsibilities on the employer who takes over the business or part thereof of another employer as a going concern.
The amended section 198 share page the amendments to the labour relations act, 66 of 1995 are expected to give rise to an influx of litigation due to the new provisions such as those providing for equal pay claims, temporary employment services employee claims and claims arising from fixed term contracts. Temporary employment whats changed for employers and. A critical analysis of section 197 of the labour relations. On the face of it, it may appear that a transfer of services from a service provider to. However, establishing the date of the transfer for purposes of labour law can be tricky. Looking to eu and uk jurisprudence sa cases show that section 197 may apply where there is a change in service provider, provided that must be service, not goods labour broker.
Traditionally, indian governments at federal and state level have sought to ensure a high degree of protection for workers, but in practice, this differs due to form of government and because labour is a subject in the concurrent list of the indian constitution. Generally, you may amortize the capitalized costs of section 197 intangibles. A recent constitutional court judgment download case here 93 in the case of city power v grinpal energy management services pty ltd proves that organs of state are not immune to. This is a revised edition of the law, prepared by the law revision commissioner under the authority of the law revision act, chapter 3 of the laws of belize, revised edition 1980 1990. Section 198 of the labour relations act lra says a labour broker is anyone who gets money for supplying workers to a client company and pays the. If the retrenchment takes place after the transfer, only the new. Why are the indian it companies exempted from labour laws. One of the reasons for the 2006 transnet strike was the concern of employees of a transnet subsidiary over their transfer to an entity controlled by the department of transport.
The facts, as well as the questions of law that may arise, have been. Section 197 2c effectively allows the employee to sue the new employer even if it was the old employer who retrenched the employee unfairly. As a training provider we commit to professionalism and the use of up to date material and information, presented through the means of the latest methology. Section 197 of the labour relations act lra requires the new employer, in a takeover as a going concern, to take over all the employees of the old employer. Section 197 of the labour relations act states the following. This is a handy checklist to be used for the sale or transfer of any business, trade, undertaking or service or any part thereof, as a going concern to ensure compliance with the lra. Nov 15, 2019 it sector is not exempted from labour laws as such. Labour act, 2003 an act to amend and consolidate the laws relating to labour, employers, trade unions and industrial relations.
Indian labour law refers to laws regulating labour in india. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra was enacted to change the common law position, with the effect that an automatic transfer of contracts of employment from the transferring employer previous employer to the acquiring. One of the functions of labor laws is to eliminate discriminatory practices in hiring and the workplace. The section is essentially aimed at minimising the conflict that arises from the transfer of a business and the negative impact it may have upon economic development and labour stability. Section 197 of the labour relations act, 1995 the lra was enacted to regulate the employment consequences where the whole or a part of a. Section 197 intangibles do not include any interest in computer software that is. The legal question that arose was whether such insourcing would trigger section 197 of the labour relations act the lra, which sets out the employee transfer obligations on employers whenever. It also includes the terms and conditions of employment, whether contractual or. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra provides that if a transfer of business takes place, all the rights and obligations between the old employer and an employee at the time of the. Retrenchment is a specific legal process governed by sections 189 and 189a of the labour relations act. In particular, you need to be aware of section 197 which deals with the transfer of the employment contract from the old employer to the new employer.
Previously, section 197 allowed for the automatic transfers of employees when there was transfer of the whole or part of a business, trade or undertaking. The constitutional court recently delivered a judgement in the case of city power ltd v grinpal energy management services pty ltd, concerning section 197 2 of the labour relations act 66 of 1995 the lra. It also includes any term interest in any section 197 intangible, whether the interest is outright or in trust. A take over of an enterprise as a going concern essentially means that the new employer is carrying on the same business as the old employer after a takeover. The amortization deduction under section 197 is determined by amortizing basis. What this change means for south african employers. Labour laws applicable to software companies xls download. Complicheck is a next generation compliance software that helps you track and monitor regulatory and statutory compliance. While section 197 of the labour relations act, 1995 deals with transfers of a business as a going concern, the impact of the section 197 transfer on employee benefit schemes becomes a key focus in.
Section 197 of the lra deals with complex and stringent provisions. May 20, 2015 organs of state not immune to section 197 of the labour relations act may 20, 2015 salawsearch leave a comment a recent constitutional court judgment download case here 93 in the case of city power v grinpal energy management services pty ltd proves that organs of state are not immune to section 197 of the labour relations act. The labour court concluded that a transfer in terms of section 197 had taken place with effect from 1 august 2012, and that the employees had been transferred to. This practice is illegal and not acceptable morally or in terms of the labour relations act. Click on the link if you like to more information on werksmans expertise in the labour. Whereas there is a complaint made under chapter 12 of this act, or there is a labor dispute under the law on labor relations, or a lawsuit is commenced, the employer shall retain the record of employees and documents relating to the payment of wages, overtime pay, holiday pay and holiday overtime pay until the order of judgment in respect of. Therefore, when section 1972a says that if a transfer of a. Transfer of employees in terms of section 197 of the labour. Business to include the whole or part of any business, trade, undertaking or service. Employees rights under a new employer when a business is.
It is for this reason that section 197 of the labour relations act lra requires. Individual labour law concerns employees rights at work also through the contract for work. Collective labour law relates to the tripartite relationship between employee, employer and union. Your guide to labour law in south africa labour guide. New labour relations act the lra section 197 of the lra states that the contracts of employment of the existing employees are automatically transferred to the new employer subject to the provisions of the section. May 24, 2017 the section 189 retrenchment process in terms of the labour relations act section 189 of the labour relations act lra permits employers to dismiss employees for operational requirements. Labour law arose in parallel with the industrial revolution as the relationship between worker and employer changed from smallscale production studios to largescale factories. This edition contains a consolidation of the following laws page arrangement of sections 3 labour act 17 amendments in force as at 31st december, 2000. This section forces the new employer to take over all the labour related obligations of the old employer. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra was enacted to change the common law position, with the effect that an automatic transfer of contracts of employment from the transferring. The termination of a franchise agreement by the franchisor does not in itself constitute a transfer of a business as a going concern, even if the franchisor thereafter. Sec 1871g of the act is to the effect that a dismissal for a transfer of a business as. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra was enacted to change the common law position, with the effect that an automatic transfer of contracts of employment from the transferring employer previous employer to the acquiring employer new employer now takes place in the event that the.
This law is formulated in accordance with the constitution in order to protect the legitimate rights and interests of labourers, readjust labour relationship, establish and safeguard a labour system suited to the socialist market economy, and promote economic development and social progress. Section 197 provides for the transfer of employment contracts upon the transfer of a business. Workers who work in this way are the workers of the labour broker, not of the client company. Dismissal related to transfer of business sme toolkit sa. The constitutional court recently delivered a judgement in the case of city power ltd v grinpal energy management services pty ltd, concerning section 197 2 of the labour relations act 66 of 1995. As a training provider we commit to professionalism and. If so, then make sure that you know about and comply with the provisions of the labour relations act. Checklist section 197 of labour relations act, document. A transfer of a going concern is not applicable as this is an implied transfer. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra provides that if a transfer of business takes place, all the rights and obligations.
Section 197 of the labour relations act, 1995 the lra was enacted to regulate the employment consequences where the whole or a part of a business or service is transferred as a going concern. Title checklist section 197 of labour relations act description section 197 of the lra must be strictly adhered to. The amended section 198 share page the amendments to the labour relations act, 66 of 1995 are expected to give rise to an influx of litigation due to the new. Can the new owner of a business dismiss existing employees. These are defined as requirements based on economic, technological, structural or similar needs of the employer. Transfer of employees in terms of section 197 of the. Whereas there is a complaint made under chapter 12 of this act, or there is a labor dispute under the law on labor relations, or a lawsuit is commenced, the employer shall retain the record of employees and. The legal question that arose was whether such insourcing would trigger section 197 of the labour relations act the lra, which sets out the employee transfer obligations on employers whenever there is a transfer of business as a going concern. Outsourcing 2019 laws and regulations south africa iclg. In other words, provided that the nature of a transaction is such that it falls within the ambit of section 197, the consequence of an automatic and obligatory substitution of the transferor employer. Uttar pradesh brings ordinance to suspend most labour laws for 3 years 07 may, 2020, 11. In particular, you need to be aware of section 197 which deals with the transfer of the. Jul 15, 2016 a contentious aspect of our labour law is the balancing of rights of an employer and its employees during the transfer of a business as a going concern. The ordinance however will not apply to certain laws like the bonded labour act.
What are the employment implications of the transfer of a business. This section looks at labour relations, trade unions, boards and tribunals, employment standards, collective agreements and arbitration of labour disputes from all. By referring to the employment relationship as transferring from the tes to the client of the tes, it could. If the retrenchment takes place after the transfer, only the new employer can be sued. What are the employment implications of the transfer of a. Working on a variety of commercial agreements including outsourcing agreements including all labour law issues in respect of section 197, software licence agreements, ip ownership and other complex. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 provides that when a business is transferred as a going concern, the effect is that employees of that business automatically become employed by the. Ensure that you make an appointment to meet with an experienced labour law attorney, such as those in the caf labour law department, prior to exercising any of the aforementioned provisions.
While section 197 of the labour relations act, 1995 deals with transfers of a business as a going concern, the impact of the section 197 transfer on employee benefit schemes becomes a key focus in the transfer. During the 20th century there was a development from selectivity to universalism in labour law, and then back to selectivity of a different kind. The agreement must be in writing and concluded between either the old employer, the new employer, or the old and new employers acting jointly on the one hand, and a relevant consulting party or body or referred to in section 189, on the other hand. A contentious aspect of our labour law is the balancing of rights of an employer and its employees during the transfer of a business as a going concern. To use the metaphor relied upon by pro fessor ivance kalula in his inaugural lecture. For example, if the cost of computer software is not separately stated from the cost of. According to the equal employment opportunity commission, title vii of the. Section 197 of the labour relations act 66 of 1995 regulates the transfer of a business as a going concern. The agreement must be in writing and concluded between either the old employer, the new employer, or the old and new employers acting.
The ordinance however will not apply to certain laws like the bonded labour act, building and other construction workers act, section 5 of payment of wages act and workmen compensation act. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 lra provides that if a transfer of business takes place, all the rights and obligations between the old employer and an employee at the time of the transfer continue as if they had been the rights and obligations between the new employer and the employee. Section 197 of the labour relations act, no 66 of 1995 provides that when a business is transferred as a going concern, the effect is that employees of that business automatically become employed by the new owner of the business, without the need for new contracts of employment between the employees and the new owner. Transfer of employment contracts section 197 labour law. The sale of a business as a going concern takes place subject to the provisions of the lra. By referring to the employment relationship as transferring from the tes to the client of the tes, it could ring the section 197 alarm bells. Section 1862d classifies as an unfair labour practice any. Second generation transfers in terms of section 197 of the lra. Cityindiabangalore countryindia dear all employee state insurance human element indian law it company labour acts labour law labour laws labour legislations maternity benefit provident fund state insurance. Organs of state not immune to section 197 of the labour. The termination of a franchise agreement by the franchisor does not in itself constitute a transfer of a business as a going concern, even if the franchisor thereafter appoints another franchisee in the same area, and serving the same customers, as the previous franchisee. The purpose of section 197 is analysed, with specific reference to the legal lacuna.
1430 1407 1035 282 659 1359 1124 801 29 1285 1281 599 504 1031 294 1606 513 1247 1179 1589 116 439 211 99 252 805 1001 625 1479 139 486 1472 1280 1116 642 375 223 172 761 1167